Creatively Endeavored #16 – Top 5 Stars WWE Dropped The Ball On
by Matthew Harrak on December 29, 2011

I have a 9-month-old boy who just started crawling and therefore destroying the house. I work a full-time job that’s anywhere from 40-60 hours a week. I’m the host of Inside Pulse’s new radio show the “Wrestling Pulsecast” where I interview someone from the world of professional wrestling every week at 7:30 PM EST on BlogTalkRadio. I also run my own wrestling website where I cover every big show along with features such as original wallpapers, articles, videos, etc. And because of all of this and so much more I won’t mention, I haven’t written a full article in months. And that blows.

I love to write. It’s my hobby (along with this other thing we all tend to talk about on this site) and it’s something I just don’t get that much time for anymore. It’s been bothering me for a while that I haven’t been able to find the non-existent time to lock the office door and come up with a well thought out and reasoned article analyzing this entertaining sport we all love.

Why should I? I have a beautiful wife I love doing everything with. An awesome son that becomes more active everyday. Friends and family I don’t see nearly enough of as it is. And business ventures that I’m constantly exploring and improving. But the thing is, no matter how hard I try to get away and no matter how easy the companies make it to give up on them, professional wrestling has been ingrained into my DNA since I was three years old and nothing has the power to change that.

That being said, I’m sick of not writing. Sick of feeling like all of these good ideas will never see the light of a computer screen. So I’m making a change. Nothing too significant and honestly if you’ve never read my work before, you won’t even notice a difference. It’s just a format change for “Creatively Endeavored”. Instead of fighting the losing battle every week of a daunting editorial, CE is transferring to a more reader (and writer) pleasing “Top 5″ style of article. I’m hoping this change will encourage more reader interaction and inspire lively debates.

This first piece is a new beginning where we’ll look at guys who didn’t really get their own shot at a new beginning. With the recent news of the departure of John Morrison from the WWE, it made me nostalgic for other pro-wrestlers who seemed as if they were on the verge of stardom, just to slowly fade away into nothingness. So this relaunch of “Creatively Endeavored” will take a look at the Top 5 Wrestlers WWE Dropped The Ball On.

 

#5: John Morrison/Colt Cabana

- John Morrison is a strange case. At the beginning of his career as Eric Bischoff’s assistant Johnny Nitro, many believed he had the look, personality and athletic ability to be a star in the future. That didn’t pan out and he was sent to OVW. His next run included Melina and Joey Mercury for the successful tag team MNM. After the split and a failed singles run on Smackdown, Nitro reinvented himself on ECW as John Morrison is a good feud with the emerging CM Punk. On ECW, Morrison discovered a chemistry he had with The Miz and another successful tag team was formed. Once they split, many though Morrison would become the next Shawn Michaels but he could never truly break out. He was stuck in the same rut for the last two years right up to his release. Could he have succeeded if given a better shot? Possibly but he was given a few opportunities. There’s no denying that he has the look and in-ring ability that if the WWE machine wanted to get behind him, we would probably be talking about another John Morrison/CM Punk feud right now.

Colt Cabana is the polar opposite. An excellent talent that WWE had signed to Smackdown and just let slip away. The potential for Cabana was immeasurable and he’s proven in the years since his release that he is a strong worker with an intense drive to succeed that would have thrived in the right environment. Cabana is still young enough that if WWE wanted to take another chance on him, he could surely contribute to any show. The stars just do not seemed to be aligned though.

 

#4: Curt Hennig

- “Mr. Perfect” Curt Hennig might seem like an odd choice for this list but hear me out. The highest Hennig reached in the then-WWF was the upper mid-card and the Intercontinental Championship. Hennig’s feuds with Brutus Beefcake, Texas Tornado, Ultimate Warrior, Ric Flair and Bret Hart consistently stole the show and his early program with Hulk Hogan proved he could hang in the main event. Unfortunately WWE didn’t capitalize early enough on his abilities and a serious back injury forced Hennig to the announce booth. Curt made a return to the ring years later for WCW and while he was still stellar in the ring, his prime was past and we never really got to see that great main event run.

 

#3: Goldberg

- Goldberg is arguably WCW’s greatest homegrown talent. In one year, Bill Goldberg went from training in the Power Planet to pinning Hulk Hogan for World Heavyweight Championship in a sold out Georgia Dome. In WWE, Goldberg plowed through the Rock, was one upped by Jericho week after week and wore Goldust’s wig. Eventually he captured the World title but the damage was done. Goldberg only lasted one year in the WWE and booed out of the company at WrestleMania 20 in Madison Square Garden.

 

#2: Dusty Rhodes

- Before “The American Dream” came to the then-WWF in 1989, Dusty Rhodes had been a 3 time NWA World Heavyweight Champion (among numerous other titles in a plethora of territories.) In 1991, Rhodes left the WWF without a single championship, two sub par feuds with Randy Savage and Ted DiBiase and retired from the ring as a full-time wrestler. For a man who many consider to be the most charismatic man ever to lace up a pair of boots, there’s no way to look at this WWF run as anything but disappointing.

 

#1: Ricky Steamboat

- Ric Flair has named Ricky Steamboat the “best babyface of all-time” on more than one occasion. His hour-long matches with Flair defined a generation and his match with Randy Savage at WrestleMania 3 is widely considered one of the best in history. The talent Steamboat had to rally a crowd behind him was unmatched on a national and international level. To borrow a line from Chris Jericho, he was the best in the world at what he did. But Steamboat was also a family man and the wrestling business is well-known for being just the opposite of that. The then-WWF wanted their top talent to work over 300 days a year and family time was just something Steamboat would not sacrifice. Once management realized this, Steamboat lost the Intercontinental Title, was “injured”, sacked with an actual dragon outfit upon his return and eventually banished to the wasteland of early 90s WCW. WWE had probably the second best babyface of the 80s (behind Hogan) and not only did they not capitalize on that, they dropped him from the company entirely.

 

Honorable Mentions:
Michael McGillicutty
Kaval
Sin Cara
MVP
Scott Hall
Diamond Dallas Page
Sean O’Haire


Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Related Columns Articles

more articles »

REALLY?!?!?! with CB – The Summer of Live Impact, Starring ZOMG Brooke Hogan!!!!

Interinactivity: 05.18.2012 – Brock Lesnar, John Cena, & Hulk Hogan

REALLY?!?!?! with CB - 3-Hour Monday Night Raw is ZZZZzzzzz

The Stomping Ground: Shotgun Booking + Brock Lesnar = Catastrophe?

Matthew Harrak

view profile »
  • Michael L

    I’d also include Vader on the list. Although his reputation was slightly tarnished from being Hogan’s bitch throughout 1995, he was still regarded as a monster who loved to hurt people. Unfortunately, once he lost the Summerslam WWF title match against Michaels, they never knew what to do with him. Although he had a solid program against Undertaker, that was about it. They blew a chance to have a killer program with Mankind/Mick Foley, which would really have helped his career. Then they turn him face for no real reason, and he essentially served as cannon fodder for Kane throughout 98 before jobbing to Bradshaw on his way out.

    I’d also include Raven on the list of talents the WWE dropped the ball on. Actually, I’m not sure what the hell they did with him other than giving him a handful of hardcore title runs. He could easily have been a solid midcarder, with an IC title run, but instead, he wound up with Sunday Night Heat as his venue.

  • SuperJ

    We cant forget Rick Rude. He was able to get the entire crowd hating on him, thereby making any face he was up against the most cheered person in the building. The fact that the best he ever got was the IC title is criminal.

  • Anonymous

    Ric Flair comes to mind in terms of WWF dropping the ball. The fact he and Hogan could never agree on a match and WWF couldn’t make it happen is a travesty.

  • Mike Gojira

    Spot on with those picks, Matt. It’s a shame some of those guys will never get that shining moment, what with them either being too old or too dead.

    However, look at it from this perspective: isn’t the very fact we cry foul over how they were treated evidence enough that they were able to achieve so much without holding a piece of leather with metal adorning it?

  • http://twitter.com/BlairADouglas Blair A. Douglas

    Good article, and… MICHAEL MCGILLICUTTY?!?!

  • Sideshowbob

    He commentated. Johnny Polo. He was actually pretty good at it even though I don’t think they ever said how or why he would have any insight…

  • Sideshowbob

    Yeah I think CB nailed it with Hogan-Flair.
    I completely disagree with Goldberg though. He wasn’t into it, thought he was better than the show, and was a 5 move guy. that would be like saying they dropped the ball with Warrior. They didn’t drop the ball, those two were lightning in a bottle their first time around, and second showing exposed their limitations

  • Joe

    I agree with Sideshow on Goldberg. He definitely wasn’t into it. Plus, hes more along the lines of them dropping the ball on capitalizing on WCW at the time of purchase.

    I don’t think Morrison’s name belongs on here at all. He’s a guy good at hitting spots and lousy on the mic, unless he’s paired with someone golden on the mic making up for it as with Miz. They dropped the ball with him about as much as they did with Shelton Benjamin. Both are fun to watch, but boring as he’ll to follow.

    I’ll go ahead and toss Jake Roberts in here. That dude remains one of the most over guys ever, and I would have loved a full blown good vs evil feud with Hogan in the late 80s.

  • Zork

    I think Sin Cara and Scott Hall dropped their own balls…wow that sounds weird.

    Seriously though, their situations are mostly their own fault. Scott never had aspirations to be anything more than a midcard guy apparently, Sin Cara is apparently (stressing that apparently) annoying backstage and hard to work with.

    Morrison doesn’t feel like a good choice either, I think after a few years people wisened up to his weaknesses, but I still think he’d make a better heel. He just felt more natural and believable in that old character that he played with Miz and on ECW.

    I’ll throw in my thoughts with Raven, Vader, and Rick Rude. Yeah, those guys deserved better for sure. Jake Roberts created his own problems too, but unlike Scott Hall I think he did want to be a part of the bigger picture.

  • Biff

    Sean O’Haire should have been #1, IMO. The guy was money, could talk, great worker, great look. He could have been a HUGE star. The fueds he could have had…what a waste.

  • Matt

    LOVE the comment thread and this is what I hoped would happen with the new format change. Thanks guys.

    A couple opinions of the comments:

    - While Goldberg didn’t have much to work with, WCW had built up equity in the character that would have been successful in the WWE. However, WWE’s mentality of having to tear down character’s of someone else creation and build them back up destroyed all the mystique of Goldberg in the WWE and Bill Goldberg himself lost all faith in the creative process.

    - Morrison is tough because it did seem like he had a lot of chances. But the mark where he quickly declined was when he was turned babyface. Keep him heel, let him be sarcastic and you just might have a top guy.

    - Ric Flair and Rick Rude are too other good picks but I thought Flair had accomplished enough in the WWF/WWE that his runs don’t seem like failures even though a feud with Hogan seemed like a missed opportunity.

  • Anonymous

    But for Flair and WWF to NOT do the Flair-Hogan match, I equate it to boxing today not being able to get Mayweather – Pacquiao done.

  • Matt

    True but my argument is that not having the match didn’t hurt Flair’s career/legacy

  • Pingback: GREGORY: 2011 was a banner year for local sports | Engine Analysis Software

Blowing Up Blogs

Recent Comments

Search Pulse

Author:

Zone:

Category:

wwe
tna
So, with this Simple Jquery Modal Window, it can be in any shapes you want! Simple and Easy to modify : )