Loading
| Date | Champion | Defeated |
| 09.21.02 | Christopher Daniels & Donovan Morgan | American Dragon & Michael Modest |
| 03.15.03 | AJ Styles & The Amazing Red | Christopher Daniels & Xavier |
| 09.06.03 | VACATED | Amazing Red injured |
| 09.20.03 | The Backseat Boyz | Izzy & Dixie |
| 10.16.03 | Izzy & Dixie | The Backseat Boyz |
| 11.01.03 | Mark & Jay Briscoe | Izzy & Dixie |
| 04.24.04 | CM Punk & Colt Cabana | Mark & Jay Briscoe |
| 05.15.04 | CM Punk & Colt Cabana (2) | Mark & Jay Briscoe |
| 05.15.04 | Mark & Jay Briscoe (2) | Dan Maff & BJ Whitmer |
| 05.15.04 | Dan Maff & BJ Whitmer | CM Punk & Colt Cabana |
| 08.07.04 | Ricky Reyes & Rocky Romero | CM Punk & Colt Cabana |
| 02.19.05 | Dan Maff & BJ Whitmer (2) | Ricky Reyes & Rocky Romero |
| 03.28.05 | VACATED | Dan Maff injured |
| 04.02.05 | BJ Whitmer & Jimmy Jacobs | Samoa Joe & Jay Lethal |
| 07.09.05 | The Carnage Crew | BJ Whitmer & Jimmy Jacobs |
| 07.23.05 | BJ Whitmer & Jimmy Jacobs (2) | The Carnage Crew |
| 10.01.05 | Tony Mamaluke & Sal Rinauro | BJ Whitmer & Jimmy Jacobs |
| 12.17.05 | Austin Aries & Roderick Strong | Tony Mamaluke & Sal Rinauro |
| 09.16.06 | The Kings of Wrestling | Austin Aries & Roderick Strong |
| 11.25.06 | Christopher Daniels & Matt Sydal | The Kings of Wrestling |
| 02.24.07 | Jay & Mark Briscoe (3) | Christopher Daniels & Matt Sydal |
| 03.03.07 | Naruki Doi & Shingo | Jay & Mark Briscoe |
| 03.30.07 | Jay & Mark Briscoe (4) | Naruki Doi & Shingo |
| 12.30.07 | Jimmy Jacobs & Tyler Black | Jay & Mark Briscoe |
| 01.26.08 | Rocky Romero & Davey Richards | Bryan Danielson & Austin Aries |
| 04.12.08 | Jay & Mark Briscoe (5) | Rocky Romero & Davey Richards |
| 05.11.08 | VACATED | Mark Briscoe injured |
| 06.06.08 | Jimmy Jacobs & Tyler Black (2) | Kevin Steen & El Generico |
| 09.19.08 | Kevin Steen & El Generico | Jimmy Jacobs & Tyler Black |
| 04.10.09 | The American Wolves | Kevin Steen & El Generico |
| 12.19.09 | Jay & Mark Briscoe (6) | The American Wolves |
| 04.03.10 | The Kings of Wrestling (2) | Jay & Mark Briscoe |
| 04.01.11 | Wrestling's Greatest Tag Team | The Kings of Wrestling |
| 12.23.11 | Jay & Mark Briscoe (7) | Wrestling's Greatest Tag Team |
| 05.12.12 | Wrestling's Greatest Tag Team (2) | Jay & Mark Briscoe |
| 06.24.12 | The All Night Express | Wrestling's Greatest Tag Team |
| 07.10.12 | VACATED | Kenny King signs with TNA |
| 09.15.12 | Jimmy Jacobs & Steve Corino | Rhett Titus & Charlie Haas |
Titles that are still actively defended
Titles which have been retired or unified
